In 1222, written in 2011, Hanne is on a
train heading to the west coast of Norway for a medical appointment in Bergen
when the train derails at the tunnel on the edge of the mountain town of Finse.
Tossed
about in the wreck the wheelchair bound Hanne ends up with a baby on her lap
and a ski pole stuck through her thigh. With no feeling below her waist Hanne
was unaware of the injury.
Rescuers
work efficiently to transport the guests to an almost empty resort hotel as a
fierce winter storm, we would call it a blizzard in Saskatchewan, envelops the
town.
With
heavy snow and strong wind forecast for several days the travelers will be
forced to sit out the storm at the hotel.
It is the
first time I have read a form of country home mystery caused by a blizzard. It
is a setting I can clearly identify with after 63 Saskatchewan winters. Holt
writes with the conviction and experience of a person who has experienced a
ferocious storm that makes even venturing outside dangerous.
Everyone
who has grown up or lived in Saskatchewan can appreciate the fury of a
blizzard. I have experienced days when you could barely see buildings across
the road and, when it was dark, could see nothing.
Survival
is dependent on shelter. You cannot stay alive in the open during a blizzard.
The cruel wind will work its way through any clothing and any exposed flesh
will start freezing in minutes.
Buildings
are rarely threatened by blizzards. As long as you are inside with heat and
electricity a blizzard can be an adventure.
For the
train passengers the excitement of surviving the wreck and being storm stayed
swiftly abates.
When
Church minister, Cato Hammer, tries to encourage the passengers to be thankful
he is basically shouted down.
Hanne is
unpleasant. She refuses a room insisting she stay in her chair. She is abrupt
with those wanting to talk to her. She is rude to anyone wanting to help her.
Her prickly personality soon leaves her alone in the busy hotel.
Dr.
Marcus Streng, who has treated her injury and confidently stated she will
recover, ignores her barbs and visits with her. Since he is a dwarf Hanne can
hardly think he is condescending towards her because of her disability.
When Cato
is found murdered Hanne, a homicide officer in the Oslo police until she
suffered the spinal injury that left her a paraplegic, hotel and local leaders
look to her. She is uninterested in an investigation but cannot escape the
compulsion of a lifetime to carefully observe those around her.
She is
aided by Geir Rugholmen, a lawyer from Bergen who has come to his apartment to
work on his kitchen for a week and aided in the rescue. He is clearly a good
man but I did not find he caught my attention.
With the
investigation almost a non-investigation and the sleuth an uninterested
investigator the plot was slow moving until the last 100 pages.
There
were few characters I really liked in the book. It was actually a long way into
the book before I started to like Hanne. She had been so determined to be
aloof. Gradually Holt won me over as Hanne slowly involves herself in the
investigation. It should not matter that Hanne was not really likeable but her
attitude affected me.
I was
pleasantly surprised there was a conference at the end of the book of the type
Nero Wolfe specialized in to uncover the murderer. Hanne is a worthy successor
to Wolfe in publicly analyzing the evidence and identifying the killer.
Were The Lion’s Mouth not on the table beside
me I am not sure if I would read another in the series. 1222 was an alright book but no more for me.
This book felt like an outlier to me too (I read it first because it was translated first), and if you are looking for more political or more of a thriller or police procedural, Holt's other books in the Wilhelmsen series or the Vik & Stubo series feel twistier to me. I was just looking over my reviews, and I realize it's been awhile since I've read the Wilhelmsen series, but while waiting for translations to be released, I read the three Vik & Stubo books, which I quite liked.
ReplyDeleteBTW, I think you're brave for reading a blizzard book this time of year. The snow melted in the Michigan woods about 2 months ago, and I'm soaking up as much warm weather as I can!
RebeccaK: Thanks for the comment. My next post will be a review of The Lion's Post. I will think about the Vik & Stubo series.
DeleteNo problem reading about winter when I am sitting on my deck listening to the birds sing and a soft wind blowing around me.
You have an interesting point, Bill, about Hanne Wilhelmsen's prickliness. She is hard to like at first, and I think Holt did that deliberately. But like you, I started to see more to her. And you're right; that snowstorm is effectively done. Anyone who's ever lived through a real one will relate to that part of the novel.
ReplyDeleteMargot: Thanks for the comment. I have this contrariness in me. I do not want sleuths to be bland but I do not want too prickly.
DeleteI have this book, Bill, but I won't read it until I have read more of the earlier books in the series, although you did make me curious. I read the first one, Blind Goddess, but I have not reviewed it yet. I had mixed reactions, but I liked it well enough to continue with the series. I did like the first book in the Vik and Stubo series better.
ReplyDeleteTracyK: Thanks for the comment. I look forward to your review of Blind Goddess. Holt has produced such varied reactions in readers.
DeleteI liked this book, but its complexity and Hanne's prickly personality made her more interesting than the usual detective's. I like variety in crime fiction.
ReplyDeleteReading about a formerly healthy investigator who becomes disabled and then bitter is understandable. Her entire life changed, and she cannot do what she used to do and wants to do.
But her intelligence and investigating skills haven't left her.
People with disabilities, like everyone else, aren't always pleasant and gracious. And if Salvo Montalbano can get cranky and obnoxious -- and lose the social graces -- while he deals with his aging crisis, surely a severely disabled smart investigator can be a curmudgeon, too.
Kathy D.: Thanks for the comment. Curmudgeons can be interesting but if there is only darkness in their lives I find it harder to keep reading.
ReplyDeleteTrue. Montalbano and Nero Wolfe are curmudgeons but not all the time.
ReplyDeleteI think reading about Hanne's life's developments book by book will explain why she is so bitter.
I think about the woman here who was an Olympic swimmer, Amy Van Dykstrem (I'm guessing at the spelling), and was then in a terrible accident. She's now in a wheelchair but works hard every day to try to walk and has a very upbeat, driven personality.
I wonder about the differences in people and characters when confronted by terrible adversity.