A blog reviewing mystery books, with a listing of Saskatchewan mysteries, and a sprinkling of non-fiction books, especially history and biographies
▼
Monday, January 17, 2011
A Duty to the Dead by Charles Todd
1. - 514.) A Duty to the Dead by Charles Todd – The mother/son duo start a new mystery series with Bess Crawford, an English nurse, set during WW I. Their Ian Rutledge series is set after the War. It only occurred to me that I read several series (Todd, Airth, Winspear) where the effects and experiences of WW I are pivotal to the series but I cannot recall a single series where WW II is as important to the lives of the characters and the nature of the mysteries. The book starts impressively with Crawford injured in the sinking of the Britannica, a hospital ship, by a mine. The uncertainty and confusion and danger of a sinking ship are vividly described. As she recovers Crawford reflects on the message entrusted to her by Arthur Graham, a dying English officer, who had asked her to take word back to his brother that he lied for the sake of his mother and what happened must be set right. Honouring her obligation to the dead she travels to the Graham home Owlhurst, Kent. The message is received but the family appears unresponsive. About ready to depart she is drawn deeply into the Graham family affairs by volunteering to nurse Peregrine Graham who has pneumonia. Peregrine, the oldest son, was placed in a local asylum as a teenager 14 years earlier for killing a maid in London. Crawford delves into the twisted family history of the Grahams as she feels the need to carry out, not just deliver, Arthur’s final message. She needs all her determination to find out what must be set right. I did not like the method of the solution. It did not flow well and felt contrived. It was interesting to have internal voices play a role though not to the extent and importance of Hamish in the Rutledge series. I would read another as Crawford is fascinating. Possible hardcover. (Jan. 1/10)
1. - 514.) A Duty to the Dead by Charles Todd – The mother/son duo start a new mystery series with Bess Crawford, an English nurse, set during WW I. Their Ian Rutledge series is set after the War. It only occurred to me that I read several series (Todd, Airth, Winspear) where the effects and experiences of WW I are pivotal to the series but I cannot recall a single series where WW II is as important to the lives of the characters and the nature of the mysteries. The book starts impressively with Crawford injured in the sinking of the Britannica, a hospital ship, by a mine. The uncertainty and confusion and danger of a sinking ship are vividly described. As she recovers Crawford reflects on the message entrusted to her by Arthur Graham, a dying English officer, who had asked her to take word back to his brother that he lied for the sake of his mother and what happened must be set right. Honouring her obligation to the dead she travels to the Graham home Owlhurst, Kent. The message is received but the family appears unresponsive. About ready to depart she is drawn deeply into the Graham family affairs by volunteering to nurse Peregrine Graham who has pneumonia. Peregrine, the oldest son, was placed in a local asylum as a teenager 14 years earlier for killing a maid in London. Crawford delves into the twisted family history of the Grahams as she feels the need to carry out, not just deliver, Arthur’s final message. She needs all her determination to find out what must be set right. I did not like the method of the solution. It did not flow well and felt contrived. It was interesting to have internal voices play a role though not to the extent and importance of Hamish in the Rutledge series. I would read another as Crawford is fascinating. Possible hardcover. (Jan. 1/10)
No comments:
Post a Comment