I just finished reading Sweetheart Deal by Claire Matturo and decided to put up a post about the four book series featuring Lilly Belle Rose Cleary. In looking at my reviews I see I have not posted my review of the opening book. Tonight I will put up my review of Skinny-Dipping and follow it in a couple of days with Sweetheart Deal.
****
10.
- 420.) Skinny-Dipping by Claire
Matturro – Lilly Rose (Lillian Belle Rosemary only to her family) Cleary is the
funniest lawyer since Paul Levine’s Steve Solomon and Victoria Lord. Tall and
slim and approaching her mid-30’s Lilly is a medical malpractice defender in
Sarasota. She is gearing up to defend Dr. Trusdale, who screwed up a knee
replacement, when the doctor is found dead after partially smoking a marijuana
cigarette laced with oleander (Florida apparenly has lots of backyard toxins).
When investigating detective, Sam Santuri, finds out about two undetected
malpractice judgments in the doctor’s past Lilly shifts forthwith from
aggressive defence to immediate settlement. Her next case involving a veggie
baby looks far more difficult. As she searches for a defence she must deal with
being choked by a mugger behind her office and then being shot at by her car
(her new doctor client by her side). The book flows effortlessly as Lilly deals
with her larger than life partners and an active sex life. Lilly demonstrates
that being obsessive compulsive is a useful trait in a trial lawyer. Within 2
pages I knew the book was written by a practising lawyer. It was unintentional
but a fascinating contrast to have read Grisham’s The Power Broker immediately before
this legal thriller. Grisham and Matturro each have the gifts of interesting
lawyers and drawing the reader through their books. With a financial theme in
the solution I was reminded of Sara Paretsky’s books. Lilly could be the niece
of V.I. Warshawski. Hardcover. (Feb. 29/08)
Oh, this does sound great, Bill. I like the wit mixed in with the story, and it sounds as though Lilly is a really well-drawn character. And the legal theme of the novel sounds interesting, too. I'm glad you enjoyed this one.
ReplyDeleteMargot: Thanks for the comment. For Matturro legal humour is not an oxymoron.
DeleteBill, I have read a few novels about lawyers and as far as I can recall none of them were funny. I can imagine how humour might liven up otherwise serious and intense legal battles and courtroom scenes.
ReplyDeletePrashant: Thanks for the comment. A humourous comment can relieve the tension in a court proceeding. Trying to be funny on the other hand is a bad idea.
DeleteOh, gosh, I have to get this book and Paul Levin's books, too.
ReplyDeleteA niece of V.I.'s? I'm in.
My library does not have these books, so I'll have to search.
There are many legal mysteries with wit in the courtroom. It's almost a must for me.
Michael Connelly's Mickey Haller books come to mind, funny courtroom dialogue. I laugh out loud at such scenes.
And Grisham's The Rogue Lawyer comes to mine, too, and The Rainmaker. There are others of his, too.
Kathy D.: Thanks for the comment. I wish there were as many witty moments in real life court as in fictional court.
Delete