About Me

My photo
Melfort, Saskatchewan, Canada
I am a lawyer in Melfort, Saskatchewan, Canada who enjoys reading, especially mysteries. Since 2000 I have been writing personal book reviews. This blog includes my reviews, information on and interviews with authors and descriptions of mystery bookstores I have visited. I strive to review all Saskatchewan mysteries. Other Canadian mysteries are listed under the Rest of Canada. As a lawyer I am always interested in legal mysteries. I have a separate page for legal mysteries. Occasionally my reviews of legal mysteries comment on the legal reality of the mystery. You can follow the progression of my favourite authors with up to 15 reviews. Each year I select my favourites in "Bill's Best of ----". As well as current reviews I am posting reviews from 2000 to 2011. Below my most recent couple of posts are the posts of Saskatchewan mysteries I have reviewed alphabetically by author. If you only want a sentence or two description of the book and my recommendation when deciding whether to read the book look at the bold portion of the review. If you would like to email me the link to my email is on the profile page.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

New to Me Authors (January to Mach of 2012)

Kerrie Smith has a new meme at Mysteries in Paradise which welcomes posts of the best new mystery authors read between January 1 and March 31, 2012. Some contributors are posting all their new to them authors while others focus on the best. You can reach the meme by clicking here.

I had 5 new to me mystery authors in the first 3 months of 2012. The authors and the books I read from them are:

1.) Ernest Mallo author of Needle in aHaystack;

2.) Gary Disher author of The Dragon Man;

3.) Joseph T. Klempner author of FelonyMurder;

4.) Randy Wayne White author of Sanibel Flats; and,

5.) L.R. Wright author of The Suspect.

My top 3 of the quintet in the order I would rank them are:

1.) L. R. Wright;

2.) Ernest Mallo; and,

3.) Gary Disher.

There are a trio of ironies with my list.

First, each of the books is not set in the present day. Needle in a Haystack is in Argentina of the 1970’s. Felony Murder, Sanibel Flats and The Dragon Man are all in the 1990’s. Lastly, The Suspect takes place in 1984.

Second, none of the authors is new to publishing in 2011 or 2012. All are authors first published some years to a generation ago.

Third, I have not yet posted a review of The Suspect. I decided to have the list reflect when I read books rather than when I posted reviews. I will be posting my review of The Suspect on Good Friday. It is a wonderful Canadian mystery. I am alittle discouraged with myself that I had not read any of Wright’s books until this year. After reading The Suspect and looking at her website I discovered she had been born in Saskatchewan and spent part of her youth in Saskatoon.

Click over to Mysteries in Paradise. You will find interesting lists of “new to ------ authors”.

Monday, April 2, 2012

Exchange of emails with author Helmut Walser Smith on The Butcher's Tale


On Saturday I posted my review of The Butcher’s Tale. Tonight I am posting an exchange of email letters I had with the author, Professor Helmut Walser Smith that he agreed could be posted. For readers of the post who do not want detail about a non-fiction book and its conclusion it would be best not to read the letters.
****
Melfort, Saskatchewan, Canada

Dear Helmut,

My younger son, Michael, has been studying history and German at the University of Calgary. This winter he took a course in which he read The Butcher’s Tale. He recommended the book to me and gave me his copy before he left for Kassel earlier this month to complete the German portion of his double major.

After finishing a book I like to write a short personal review.
Here is my review:

Instead of repeating the review you can click on the link above.

I enjoy reading history and mysteries. It is great to have a book combining those interests.

During the day I am a lawyer with much of my practice involving litigation and have taken a look at the evidence in The Butcher’s Tale as a lawyer.

The evidence supporting the conclusion that Bernhard Masloff from the Jewish community was the killer seems weak and inconclusive to me.

I thought the evidence was strongest against the Butcher Hoffman.

If there was seduction involved I would see an 18 year old more likely to seduce another teenager than a married woman.

I did not see an explanation of where Masloff would have access to the knives and cleavers for cutting up Ernst Winter. Unless one knife did it all I find it hard to believe Masloff would have the necessary knives and cleavers. Did he have the full range of butcher’s tools? While forensic analysis of the time would be limited it should have been possible to determine whether multiple tools were used. In the end it would be more likely for a butcher to have everything necessary.

It would seem difficult for Masloff to conceal the blood and mess from carving up a body in his home. It would be far easier for a butcher to conceal the evidence.

Changing the analysis, in considering sexual liaisons, did the investigators consider a liaison between Ernst and a Jewish girl? In the book they seem to have only considered Ernst dallying with non-Jewish women.

If he corrupted a young Jewish woman it would certainly have been possible for a Jewish member of the community to have killed him for reasons that had nothing to with blood rituals.

I hope you find the time to explore other legal cases from a historian’s perspective. This mystery history was well done.

Best wishes.

Bill Selnes

****
Dear Mr. Selnes,

Thank you for sending along your kind review and comments about my book. I was also very intrigued by your observations as a lawyer. One reason I left the case open is of course that there was for Maslow, as you rightly point out, inconclusive evidence. This has partly to do with criminal investigations of the time. Less than 50% of the murder cases were ever solved. It also has to do with the very late date in which they took Masloff seriously as a suspect, so that had there been a mess in the cellar (and had the murder taken place there), roughly a year had already passed.

Yes--it was perhaps more likely for Winter to be with a teenager then a married woman, though in the social class to which Maslow belonged, these things happened. I don't have the book with me, and the material is now over six years old, but I think the age difference was not that far apart.

In the documents, there is no detailed information on which utensils were used. You are right to think that this should have been a major consideration. There was some suggestion however that the cuts were amateurish, though not clueless.

The anti-Semites tried to show that Winter was dallying with Jewish girls. But there was no evidence. Precisely because Jewish communities were so nervous about blood libel charges, the thought that they might retaliate if a Christian boy seduced one of their girls seems unbelievable. In fact, the Jewish community was extremely small compared to the Christian.

Finally, I actually suspect that neither Maslow nor Hoffmann killed Winter, but someone else. The dilettantish investigations made figuring this out impossible--at least for me.

Thanks again for your comments, best, helmut

Saturday, March 31, 2012

The Butcher’s Tale by Helmut Walser Smith

Three years ago my son, Michael, recommended a non-fiction book he had read in a German history class on a murder in Germany early in the 20th Century. It proved fascinating. Tonight I post my review of the book. On Monday I will post an exchange of emails with the author concerning the book.

****

17. – 480.) The Butcher’s Tale by Helmut Walser Smith – I had never realized that the myth of Jewish ritual killings at Easter for blood to be used in making Passover Matzo had persisted into the 20th Century. In 1900 Ernst Winter, a 19 year old student, was killed and dismembered in Konitz, West Prussia. Rumours arise that he was killed by the community’s Jews in a ritual murder. Attention is focused on Adolph Lewy, a butcher, for the cutting of the body was done by someone skilled in cutting meat. Riots ensue. The Jewish population is saved from physical harm because the State protects them – twice sending in the army to maintain peace. State investigators pursue non-Jewish leads but the majority of the population is convinced of Jewish culpability. Smith proceeds to a history of alleged Jewish blood murders going back to 1200. He dis cusses the systematic killing of Jews in Western Europe through the Middle Ages because of non-existent blood murders. The Vatican consistently condemned the killing of Jewish people and found no proof of ritual killings but the belief that Jews killed for blood stubbornly persisted. With such a depth of anti-Semitism simmering in the population it is far easier for me to understand how the German people would participate in the Holocaust. When the State turned against the Jews they were ready to follow. (The same murderous spirit concerning the Jews was present in enough of the Polish and Slavic populations to the East to help the Nazis kill Jews as set out in Hitler's Empire.) I have a better understanding why Jewish people fiercely react to anti-Semitic remarks and actions. A millennium of violence over the blood libel is barely a century past. In Monday's post will be the exchange of letters with Smith on the investigation and a startling statement from the author with regard to the murder that is not within the book. It is an excellent book. (May 6/09)

Thursday, March 29, 2012

“M” is for Mystery Bookstore is No More

Last year as part of my posts about mystery bookstores I have visited I put up a post about the “M” is for Mystery Bookstore in San Mateo, California. It was a lovely store and I enjoyed my visit there during a trip to San Francisco.

Unfortunately, “M” is no more. Owner, Ed Kaufman, closed the store in January of this year. While another bookstore, Third Avenue Bookstore, will occupy the space it is sad that “M” is gone.

Ed said that he had been a lawyer for 41 years and then a bookstore owner for 16 years. At 81 it was time for him to stop owning the store.

It was obvious even from meeting Ed for only a couple of times that he loved books and loved authors.

It is ironic that the store is being awarded a Raven Award at The Edgars banquet next month.

I wish I was writing about the opening of a new mystery bookstore.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Sanibel Flats (1990) by Randy Wayne White

Sanibel Flats (1990) by Randy Wayne White – M.D. “Doc” White, 36 years old, has returned home to Sanibel Island on the Florida Gulf Coast after serving in a secretive U.S. government agency in the fictional Central American country of Masagua (a thinly disguised Nicaragua).

Trained as a marine biologist he buys a stilt house and sets up a pen in the ocean next to his home for some large bull sharks. To earn income he is dissecting small bull sharks and shipping them to schools to be studied.

High school classmate and fellow Vietnam veteran, Rafe Hollins, contacts him. After the break up of a bad marriage Hollins lost custody of his son when his wife began an affair with the judge. Taking his 8 year old son Hollins, a pilot, becomes involved in some shady transport from Masagua. He swears he was not flying drugs. He is seeking Doc’s help as he has stolen from his Masaguan suppliers and they have kidnapped his son. Before Doc can work out a plan he finds Hollins dead on an island hideout.

The authorities at Sandy Key who have authority over Hollins death have no interest in an investigation and swiftly determine it was a suicide.

Back at Sanibel, Doc is being wooed by Jessica McLure, a lovely neighbour, who is a painter. It is Jessica who wants to turn the friendship intimate.

Doc has strong morals in business but his relationships with women are hardly honourable. His attitude helps keep him from being perfect but it is certainly chauvinistic.

It is not hard to figure out what Doc will do about his friend’s son being held captive but how it takes place is both clever and chilling.

One of the reasons the quest is interesting is Doc being joined by Tomlinson, an eccentric ocean neighbour with a Ph.D. from Harvard, whose life has been on a meandering course because of his affection for recreational pharmaceuticals.

I was struck by similarities between Doc and Travis McGee. Both are big articulate men. They are veterans who fought in the Vietnam and Korean Wars respectively. Each lives on the Florida coast in the ocean – Doc in the house on stilts and Travis in his famous houseboat. Each has a stern moral code. Neither has serious long term relationships with women.

They have comparable attitudes a generation apart on the development of Florida. Each condemns the relentless urbanization of the Florida coastal areas. They disdain the driving habits of the crowds upon the highways of the state.

The book has some philosophy and deft dialogue that also brought to mind John D. Macdonald. An example is Tomlinson’s reflection on danger:

“You know what I think about danger? I think if you’re walking on thin ice anyway, why not dance?”

There is a brisk pace to the book. I understand why the series is popular. There are interesting characters. Doc fits well into the classic American loner in pursuit of justice.

One of the early books in the series I want to read another before reaching conclusions about the series. It is entertaining thriller fiction. I expect I would have enjoyed it even more had I been able to go read it on the beach after buying it at the Murder on the Beach bookstore. (Mar. 21/12)

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Alphabet in Crime Fiction (2012) Meme

Last year I joined the Alphabet in Crime Fiction meme hosted by Kerrie Smith at her excellent bog, Mysteries in Paradise, a few letters into the alphabet. I had a posting for all the remaining letters of the alphabet though a couple of my posts stretched the boundaries of the meme.

Kerrie’s rules are simple:

“Your post MUST be related to either the first letter of a book’s title, the first letter of an author’s first name, or the first letter of the author’s surname, or even maybe a crime fiction “topic”. But above all, it has to be crime fiction.”

It was fun last year coming up with a weekly post and reading the posts of other participants. Several weeks there were multiple posts of the same author or even the same book. The differing perspectives added to the enjoyment of the meme.

My posts from 2011 can be found through clicking the label on the side of the blog for the Alphabet in Crime Fiction.

It is easy to become a participant in this year’s meme.. Click here to reach Mysteries in Paradise and follow the instructions.

There are already 8 bloggers signed up to take part in the meme.

While the meme does not start until May it has prompted me to think about what I will post this year. I have taken a look at my reading over the past 12 years and am going to try to make each post about an author. I have read books by authors whose first letter of the surname covers all the letters of the alphabet.

It is going to an interesting 26 week journey through the alphabet.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Dark Voyage by Alan Furst

Dark Voyage by Alan Furst – It is the spring of 1941. With World War II well underway Furst takes us to another location on the edges of the great conflict. Captain Eric DeHaan commands the tramp freighter, Noordenham. In Tangier, Morocco, he is contacted by representatives of the intelligence department of the Dutch Government in exile. They are working with the British on missions against the Nazis.

DeHaan has spent his adult life at sea traveling the oceans of the world on modest freighters. Intelligent, unmarried by choice, he is generally content with his life but anxious to strike at the Nazis who have occupied his homeland and cut him off from his family.

With the approval of the ship’s owner he is asked to aid the Allies by undertaking a short trip along the North African coast. His cargo will be a group of British commandoes on a mission to acquire information on German electronic capabilities to find Allied ships. With over 1,500 Allied ships sunk since the start of war 1 ½ years earlier it is a desperate struggle at sea.

Over night the Noordenham is transformed into the Santa Rosa, a comparable Spanish ship, fortunately docked on the Mexican coast for repairs. With her new paint drying the Santa Rosa sails for Cape Bon. Ultimately, while costly in human life, the mission is successful.

With the success they are ordered to take the Santa Rosa on another even more dangerous voyage with the goal of further aiding the Allied efforts in the electronic sea war.

DeHaan does not hesitate to commit himself and his crew to the new mission. It was striking how little say merchant seamen of that era had in their lives. When the Captain undertakes a voyage they are required to go with him. On the Noordenham / Santa Rosa is a group of sailors exiled, like DeHaan, by the war from their homes. They include a Polish engineer, a Jewish medical student acting as the ship’s doctor, an Egyptian radio operator and a Greek Army deserter.

It was interesting to read how both the Allies and Axis nations used ships of neutral nations to further their war efforts.

They undergo remarkable adventures on their missions for England but they are not the cartoon stories of most Hollywood movies. As the ending approaches there is a buildup of tension and anticipation that drives a reader to reach the ending.

In his personal life the reflective DeHaan thinks about the intense but so brief relationships he has had ashore with women.

DeHaan and the crew are the ordinary people of war. Once again I felt as if I was reading one of John Le Carre’s spy novels. There is no glitz or glamour. There are people doing their best amidst gritty circumstances. As in a Le Carre book there is no certainty of a happy ending.

Furst weaves another superb tale of life in the shadows of the battles, intrigues and politics of Europe in World War II. (Mar. 12/12)

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

The Associate by John Grisham

10. - 473.) The Associate by John Grisham – Kyle McAvoy, son of a small town Pennsylvania lawyer, is getting ready to graduate from Yale law school. His plans to do public law for a few years before heading to the big firms of New York are turned upside down by threats related to a potential multiple date rape by his fraternity brothers early in his university life. Industrial spies get him to join the world’s biggest law firm with the intention he will provide secret information on a gigantic corporate lawsuit over the development of a new U.S. Air Force bomber. Grisham portrays the total grind of life in a New York legal factory. McAvoy starts at and goes late into the night every day. I cannot see why anyone would accept such a life. Billing is worshipped and questionably calculated. I am busy as a lawyer but I am able to carry on activities and be part of organizations. Grisham continues to create page turning plots. I raced through the book. For the first time there was a twist or two that did not ring true. The ending was subtler than I expected. I wonder what my son Jonathan, considering entry into a demanding big firm, would think of the book. The relationships and opportunities between small town and big city law in the book are so close to our lives. I hope Grisham is back to Mississippi in his next book. Hardcover one more time. (Feb. 23/09)

****

Since writing the review my son, Jonathan, has joined a big firm in Calgary. The contrast in the book between the practice of law in a huge urban centre and a small rural centre resonates deeply with me.