Havana Requiem by Paul Goldstein – Michael Seeley has returned to Boone, Bancroft, the large New York City law firm that dismissed him because of his descent into a gin bottle. Sober for a year, he is rebuilding his intellectual law litigation practice principally in the worlds of entertainment and publishing. Seeley has long been known for representing the interests of artists, famous or unknown, with regard to the legal rights related to their work.
Hector Reynoso, an aged Cuban musician, arrives in Seeley’s
Manhattan office seeking to have Seeley represent him in re-gaining the rights
to his music that he surrendered decades earlier. A chance to help a composer musician
becomes the opportunity to aid a culture when Reynoso advises he is there on
behalf of the Cuban composers of his generation – the men who made and played
music before the Cuban Revolution of 1957.
There is but a narrow window for them to pursue the return
of their music. Under American law they can serve terminations of the original
contracts but there is a finite time from the creation of the music and that
limitation period is about to expire for these men.
Earlier in his career Seeley had flourished generating large
fees for the firm from wealthy clients and personal satisfaction from pro bono
cases on behalf of struggling artists.
Reynoso explains the music of himself and his friends is not
the music of the Buena Vista Social Club. It is the music of black Cubans
inspired by their African past. It is the music of men who were banned from the
best clubs in Cuba because of their dark skin. Goldstein sets out the racism
deep in Cuban society.
Their songs were the pop music of their era and are still
appreciated by lovers of Latin music and used extensively in advertising.
Millions of dollars in royalties are being paid each year but not to the
composer musicians.
Seeley’s adrenaline surges as he realizes the case is a
return to the excitement of his law student days when he helped Professor Felix
Silver successfully challenge the U.S.S.R. which, having seized ownership of
the writings of four Russian authors, went to court in America seeking to use
copyright law to prevent the publication of the writings. Now he has an
opportunity to aid artists of another totalitarian regime take ownership of
their music.
His partners have mixed emotions about his quest. Hobie
Harriman, recently of the U.S. State Department, leads the opposition. He
argues these poor old men are not the clients a rising big firm wants to
represent and the firm should pursue the representation of big business. After
a close vote Seeley is allowed to proceed.
What looks straight forward becomes mysterious and complex
when Reynoso disappears from New York City.
Seeley travels to Cuba to get the necessary documents signed
by the Cubans. With Americans officially barred from direct travel to Cuba he
flies to Canada so he can get to Cuba.
He finds in Cuba a faltering socialist state.
Corruption is rising and most of the people are very poor. Goldstein provides a
vivid portrayal of a country in decay.
Complications arise immediately on his arrival. Powerful
shadowy forces are opposed to the return of the music. The strongly principled
Seeley persists.
Who knew copyright law could be the subject of a thriller?
Goldstein has created an exciting story about the ownership of music. It is a
book that melds music, race, international politics and money with copyright
law.
Seeley is a talented lawyer but his private demon, alcohol,
still taunts him in times of stress.
I can easily understand why Havana Requiem won the 2013 Harper Lee Prize for Legal Fiction. It
is a much better book than The Wrong Man
by David Ellis which was the other book on the shortlist I have read.
I appreciate a regular commenter to this blog, kathy d., who
encouraged me to read the book.
There are two earlier Michael Seeley books. I am going to
have to go find them.
Bill - I've been very much wanting to read this. I'm so glad that you enjoyed it. I find it tragic that so many musicians didn't end up benefiting financially from the music they wrote. You often find that among the old blues and jazz musicians too.
ReplyDeleteMargot: Thanks for the comment. I believe you will enjoy it. Many people suffer when they do not get legal advice before signing contracts.
ReplyDeletePaul Goldstein's two earlier books are good, the first dealing with patents on medication to treat AIDS was particularly good -- and on the right side.
ReplyDeleteThe Wrong Man was to me an escapist and fun read, meant to divert us from the routines of daily life, without much seriousness to it.
Havana Requiem is a much more intense book, full of issues everywhere, just loaded with thinking by the protagonish -- and lots of board room conniving.
I ended up liking the twists and turns, but don't agree with the political viewpoints espoused either about Cuba, which has been actively trying to get rid of racism and discrimination in many ways and also about U.S. politics and racism.
However, that said, I can't resist a good legal mystery. The plot was original, the older musicians compelling. Their plight made me think of the many destitute blues and jazz musicians in this country who were brilliant and talented, but didn't earn money from their music, songs, etc.
I will read the next Michael Seeley books. My disagreements with the author don't dissuade from reading more of his quite thought-provoking, intelligent stories, featuring a brilliant lawyer, who still is tormented b his own problems.
Kathy D.: Thanks for the further comment. Goldstein is a good storyteller. Turning intellectual property law into thrillers is a talent.
ReplyDeleteHaving never been to Cuba I cannot comment on how that nation is dealing with racial issues.
We have our own challenges in Canada.